EPCSOFTWARES
Search/

Versus

AutoCAD Plant 3D toolset vs AVEVA E3D Design

Put any two products side by side: specification, the six criteria and the EPC Index needle.

FIG. 006

AutoCAD Plant 3D toolset

Autodesk · 3D Plant Design

02040608010065EPC INDEX

The accessible entry point to intelligent plant design, bundled with AutoCAD. Ideal for smaller projects and teams; not the backbone for very large EPC programmes.

FIG. 012

AVEVA E3D Design

AVEVA · 3D Plant Design

02040608010082EPC INDEX

The reference choice for large multidiscipline plant and offshore projects, especially where the owner already runs AVEVA. Its strength is scale and maturity rather than ease of entry.

  1. 6Capability25%9
  2. 6Interoperability20%7
  3. 5Scale15%10
  4. 8Usability15%6
  5. 6Deployment10%8
  6. 8Ecosystem15%9
AttributeAutoCAD Plant 3D toolsetAVEVA E3D Design
VendorAutodeskAVEVA
Category3D Plant Design3D Plant Design
StatusActiveActive
Deploymentn/aDesktop · Cloud
LicensingSubscriptionSubscription
Standardsn/an/a
Strengths
  • Included with an AutoCAD subscription
  • Short learning curve for DWG users
  • P&ID and 3D in one toolset
  • Proven on very large, multi-site projects
  • Tight integration with AVEVA schematics, E&I and engineering data
  • Large global talent and partner pool
Considerations
  • Scales less well to large multi-site projects
  • Fewer data-centric controls than enterprise systems
  • Owner mandates rarely specify it on major projects
  • Steep learning curve and catalogue administration effort
  • Most value is realised inside the AVEVA ecosystem
  • Subscription credits need active management

§ 02

Popular match-ups

The two leading products in each category, ready to compare.