EPCSOFTWARES
Search/

Versus

Octave Aspect Pipe Stress vs Tekla Structures

Put any two products side by side: specification, the six criteria and the EPC Index needle.

FIG. 052

Octave Aspect Pipe Stress

Octave · Structural & Piping Analysis

02040608010084EPC INDEX

CAESAR II by another name and still the reference for pipe stress analysis. Its ubiquity among stress engineers and reviewers is itself a decisive advantage.

FIG. 078

Tekla Structures

Trimble · Structural & Piping Analysis

02040608010082EPC INDEX

The detailing and fabrication standard for structural steel and precast. In EPC work it sits between analysis and the shop, rather than replacing analysis software.

  1. 9Capability25%9
  2. 8Interoperability20%8
  3. 9Scale15%9
  4. 7Usability15%6
  5. 6Deployment10%7
  6. 10Ecosystem15%9
AttributeOctave Aspect Pipe StressTekla Structures
VendorOctaveTrimble
CategoryStructural & Piping AnalysisStructural & Piping Analysis
StatusActiveActive
DeploymentDesktopDesktop
LicensingCommercial licenceSubscription
StandardsPCF/IDFIFC
Strengths
  • Broad code coverage
  • PCF import from many design tools
  • Industry-wide familiarity
  • Fabrication-ready detailing
  • Strong IFC exchange
  • Concurrent multi-user modelling
Considerations
  • The new Octave name will take time to settle in specifications
  • Desktop only
  • Licensing per seat
  • Not a structural analysis program
  • Learning curve for new users
  • Subscription licensing

§ 02

Popular match-ups

The two leading products in each category, ready to compare.